ARTICLE

Millennials & Evangelism: The Plague of Emotivism

News Image By John Stonestreet/Breakpoint.org February 15, 2019
Share this article:

In 1957, the social psychologist Leon Festinger coined the term "cognitive dissonance" to describe the stress that results from holding two or more contradictory beliefs at the same time.

According to Festinger, people will attempt to alleviate the stress by either changing their minds about one of the ideas or, more commonly, convincing themselves the ideas really aren't contradictory. The latter usually results in an incoherent mess, something a recent Barna report amply demonstrates.


The report, entitled "Reviving Evangelism," found that virtually every practicing American Christian believes that "part of their faith means being a witness about Jesus." Similarly, virtually all of them agree that "the best thing that could ever happen to someone is for them to know Jesus."

This sounds like a solid foundation for "reviving evangelism," doesn't it? Yet, the same study found that "nearly half (47 percent) of practicing Christian millennials--churchgoers who consider religion an important part of their lives--believe that evangelism is wrong."

Specifically, they believe it's "wrong to share one's personal beliefs with someone of a different faith in hopes they will one day share the same faith."

If you're wondering how one can simultaneously believe that knowing Jesus is the best thing that could happen to a person and that telling that same person about Jesus is somehow wrong, you understand what cognitive dissonance means.


Making matters even more, well, dissonant, is that the same group "is more likely than any other generation to say they are gifted at sharing their faith." Nearly three quarters of them describe themselves that way.

At this point, it's tempting to talk about how participation trophies and self-affirmation statements have ruined the millennials. But the problem isn't our misguided strategies of boosting this generation's self-esteem. The problem is theological anemia.

Specifically, it's a failure of catechesis.

Evangelizing like you mean it requires going against the cultural grain. As Barna president David Kinnaman told Christianity Today, "Cultivating deep, steady, resilient Christian conviction is difficult in a world of 'you do you' and 'don't criticize anyone else's life choices' and emotivism, the feelings-first priority that our culture makes a way of life."

Notre Dame philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre has suggested that emotivism is at the heart of our current post-truth culture, and turns all statements about the good and the true into mere claims of personal preference.

Overall, the church has done a poor job of catechizing both ourselves and future generations against emotivism. In fact, as writer Samuel James argued, "The data here strongly suggests that Christian millennials are being catechized by their colleges, not churches."


Actually, I would argue that across our culture, emotivism is pushed on us way before college, and too often, it's even pushed by churches when they talk about "knowing Jesus."

What is meant by "knowing Jesus" by so many Christians is closer to "I love Swiss Almond Vanilla ice cream" than it is what the Apostles meant by it. It indicates a strong preference, but not a life-altering conviction.

The late biblical scholar Francis Martin used to tell his students "Christianity is a way of knowing, not a warm fuzzy." By "way of knowing" he meant something akin to what we at the Colson Center mean by "worldview": the truth about God, creation, and ourselves as ultimately revealed in Jesus Christ.

That's not to say our faith isn't personal. Of course it is, but for the New Testament writers, "knowing" God and Jesus Christ whom He sent isn't about making us feel good. It's about being rescued from the dominion of darkness for the kingdom of Christ.

When was the last time you heard Christianity described this starkly? If we can't remember, then we ought not be surprised by the cognitive dissonance described by the Barna report.

Originally published at Breakpoint.org - reposted with permission.




Other News

June 28, 2025Abraham Accords - Could This Be The Future Covenant Confirmed By The Antichrist?

In a rapidly shifting Middle East, a seismic announcement may be on the horizon. Senior Israeli officials, backed by confirmations from U....

June 28, 2025United Methodist Church Leads Worship With F-Bomb LGBTQ Anthem

No, this isn't satire. This actually happened. Zao MKE Church-an official United Methodist congregation-recently led its Sunday worship wi...

June 28, 2025The Rise Of The Mosquito Drone: Warfare Just Got Personal

When most people think of drones, they imagine the large, missile-laden aircraft patrolling the skies over Ukraine or buzzing across the M...

June 28, 2025Declassified Hamas Letter Reveals Astonishing Religious Fanaticism Behind Oct. 7

The document provides rare insight into the religious ideology driving Hamas. Unlike secular Palestinian nationalist groups, Hamas views t...

June 26, 2025Radical Islamic Socialist To Lead NY? - Is This America's Future?

If this is what the future of America looks like, we are in enormous trouble. A far left Muslim socialist and supporter of Hamas is the D...

June 26, 2025The Entire Country Is Facing Enormous Economic Challenges

While everyone has been preoccupied with the war in the Middle East and the anti-ICE protests going on around the nation, economic conditi...

June 26, 2025Brilliance Meets Belief: The Jesus Confession Of The Smartest Man Alive

Young-Hoon Kim, a South Korean prodigy with a documented IQ of 276 - the highest recorded in history - stunned the scientific and academic...

Get Breaking News