ARTICLE

Now They're Euthanizing Asperger's Patients: The Threat of Assisted Suicide

News Image By John Stonestreet/Breakpoint.org December 27, 2018
Share this article:

Another week... another example of how physician-assisted suicide targets the vulnerable. This time: Asperger's patients.

In 2010, 38-year-old Tine Nys was one of approximately 1,000 people euthanized in Belgium. Nys was not suffering from a terminal illness. In fact, she wasn't sick at all.


As I've mentioned before on BreakPoint, despite how it's sold around the world, inevitable death isn't a requirement for euthanasia in Belgium. The standard for eligibility is "unbearable and untreatable suffering," which has come to include psychological suffering. 

Between 2005 and 2014, 124 people diagnosed with a "mental and/or behavioral disorder" were euthanized in Belgium. These included conditions such as depression and dementia.

But in Nys case, it's wasn't even clear she was "suffering" at all, much less in an "unbearable and untreatable" sense. Nys had been diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome, a mild form of autism.

Asperger's is characterized by, among other things, difficulty in social situations and restricted interests. It's also characterized by "remarkable focus and persistence," "attention to detail," and an aptitude for recognizing patterns.

If that doesn't sound especially unbearable, you're correct. And many people agree. Venture capitalist Peter Thiel has called Asperger's a possible "big advantage" in places like Silicon Valley. In fact, the person who helped me write this commentary will tell you that he displays more than a few Asperger's characteristics, and he and I both will tell you that those characteristics help him do the amazing job he does.

If all that was "wrong" with Nys was Asperger's, then even under Belgium's absurdly lax standards, her request for euthanasia should not have been approved. And so her family filed a criminal complaint against the doctors who approved her request.

Here's the good news: the head of Belgium's euthanasia review commission announced he would no longer accept patients referred by Nys's psychiatrist, Lieve Thienpont, who, by the way, partially justified Nys's death by referring to her family as "seriously dysfunctional, wounded, (and) traumatized... with very little empathy and respect for others."

Still, this is too little, too late. As early as 2015, Belgian doctors were aware of "the high number of requests that this psychiatrist fielded and how many of them were approved."

Here's more good news: in late November, Belgian officials opened a criminal investigation into this psychiatrist, and into two other doctors concerning the circumstances of Nys's death.

The bad news is this will do nothing to roll back Belgium's culture of death. After all, Thienpont isn't the only Belgian doctor approving requests for euthanasia from people whose "unbearable and untreatable" condition is simply psychological or even autism. She's simply the doctor most associated with a practice the New York Post called "controversial" and "hotly debated." That's not the same thing as illegal.


The case of Tine Nys is more evidence that talk about protecting vulnerable people from euthanasia once the cat is out of the bag is just that, talk. Since 2002, more than 10,000 people have been euthanized in Belgium, and before Thienpont, only one other case was referred to prosecutors and that one was eventually dropped.

Once you concede that some lives are not worth living, then the criteria for what "not worth living" means will inevitably expand. Euthanasia isn't nor has it ever been about alleviating suffering. It's about personal autonomy, the "right" to live or die as you choose, and the advancement of a culture of death.

After all, it only took Belgium eight short years to go from euthanizing terminal cancer patients to killing people whom, under different circumstances, might be working in Silicon Valley.

Originally published at Breakpoint.org - reposted with permission.




Other News

November 14, 2026How Much Longer Can Americans Keep Borrowing Their Way To Survival?

Americans are drowning in record debt, borrowing just to afford the basics while the American Dream slips further out of reach. With house...

November 14, 2026Calvary Chapel Divided: Women Pastors And The Battle Over Biblical Authority

The church that helped ignite the Jesus Movement is now at the center of a growing theological firestorm. Chuck Smith’s own grandson has a...

November 14, 2026First Britain, Now America? Growing Campaign To Criminalize Criticism Of Islam

Britain has already shown the dangers of policing speech. Now New Jersey is raising the stakes. Could criticizing Islam soon make American...

November 14, 2026Death On Demand? Canada's Dangerous Path Toward Suicide Without Limits

What if the only requirement for ending your life with government assistance was that you wanted to die? No terminal illness. No unbearabl...

November 12, 2026The AI Agenda To Conquer Death

Imagine a future where a doctor tells you that AI has found a way to keep your body alive for decades longer. Then imagine that, when your...

November 12, 2026That Didn’t Take Long: Texas Democrats Already Pushing Progressive Agenda

Texas Democrats wasted no time putting their priorities on paper. The first wave of proposals is already here, promoting the LGBTQ and Isl...

November 12, 2026“Crucified” By Egypt For Leaving Islam, Christian Convert Now Faces Execution

Leaving Islam is a crime in 17 countries and punishable by death in 12 of them and every one of those countries is Muslim-majority. The la...

Get Breaking News