ARTICLE

Canada's Obsession With The "Right to Die"

News Image By Eric Metaxas/Breakpoint.org September 12, 2017
Share this article:

Canadians, or at least Canadian media elites, seem intent on creating a real-life version of what novelist P.D. James, in her novel "The Children of Men," called "quietus": that is, state-sanctioned mass suicide of the those deemed to be a burden to the rest of society.

John Stonestreet told you about a recent article in Maclean's magazine (think Time or Newsweek for our friends north of the border), that asked "Should doctors be paid a premium (for) assisting deaths?" 

The answer was a resounding "Yes!" Without such a "premium," what Canada calls "medical assistance in dying," "will exist in theory only, and not in practice."

That was just the beginning for Maclean's. The August 15, 2017 issue told the story of a palliative care doctor who decided that, in addition to providing end-of-life care to dying patients, he would assist them with the actual dying.


Not surprisingly, the story was wrapped in gauzy haze that made everyone involved appear noble beyond words: think noted humanitarian Albert Schweitzer, instead of Jack Kevorkian.

There was no hint of where this ersatz brand of "compassion" could lead. For that, you only had to look back a few months in the magazine's archives. 

A few months earlier, an article in the magazine argued that, although "It may make some people understandably uncomfortable... extending the right to assisted dying to the mentally ill is a compassionate solution."

I told you about the move to extend the so-called "right to die" to mentally ill people back in May. I told you back then that it was a terrible idea, and now that I've seen the rationale fully set forth, I'm looking for a word that's stronger than "terrible."

The piece was written by Daniel Munro of the Conference Board of Canada whose stated goal is to--and I'm not making this up--build "a better future for Canadians by making our economy and society more dynamic and competitive." According to Munro, it's "not clear why" the principle that justifies euthanasia for the terminally ill "should apply any less to people with mental illness."


That "principle" isn't compassion, which comes from the Latin for "to suffer with." No, the principle Munro and others cite is autonomy--"allowing individuals to choose the time and manner of their deaths, just as we allow people to choose how they will lead their lives."

The New Testament Greek word for compassion is "splagchnizomai." It means being moved in our guts, our bowels, in response to the suffering of others. But today, according to Macleans anyway, compassion means being careful not to violate someone's autonomy.

This enshrinement of autonomy goes a long way toward explaining why the "right to die" will not and cannot be limited to the terminally ill. 

If you begin with the assumption that people have a right to live and die as they please, then there's no good reason to limit lethal medical assistance to only one group of suffering people.

So we need to remember, as I told you in my earlier broadcast, that when a mentally-ill person says "please let me die," you can never be certain whether it's the person speaking or the mental illness speaking. 

What matters to Macleans is not interfering with how a person chooses to end their life. And that, my friends, is the exact opposite of a Christian worldview.

In James' novel, state-sanctioned quietus was the product of a society literally without a future. 

In Canada's case, it's being championed by people who claim to be working for a better future. Whatever the setting, compassion is the last thing we should call it.

Originally published at Breakpoint.org - reposted with permission.


Other News

October 19, 2017Returning ISIS Jihadists Pose Long, Uncharted Challenges for US And Europe

For months now, Western counterterrorism experts have sounded the alarm: as ISIS loses ground, foreign fighters from America and Europe ma...

October 19, 2017Track This! Olympians Now Face Implanted Chips

The head of an association of Olympic athletes wants to require anyone who participates in the Summer or Winter Games to be implanted with...

October 19, 20178 Reasons 'Transgenderism' Is Politics, Not Science

Our society has embraced the idea of allowing gender-confused small children to determine for themselves whether they are boys or girls wi...

October 19, 2017Who Do You Say That I Am?: Idols vs. The Real Jesus

These days, increasingly odd and just plain wrong answers to Jesus' question seem to be floating around everywhere, including the church. ...

October 17, 2017North Korea's Real-Life 'Doomsday Scenario' For U.S.

A single nuclear weapon fired by North Korea into the upper atmosphere of the US heartland could could fry the electrical grid with an ele...

October 17, 2017Rise Of The Gog Of Magog Coalition

More than 2,600 years ago, the prophet Ezekiel warned of a future time when a vast coalition of nations will attack Israel....

October 17, 2017Millennials Seem To Have A Problem With Free Speech

Students are being taught that opposing viewpoints are akin to intellectual violence....

Get Breaking News