ARTICLE

Foreign Hypocrisy & Israel's Borders

News Image By Daniel Kryger/JNS.org November 09, 2018
Share this article:

When asked about the two-state solution, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu repeated quite recently his long-standing policy that the Arab population in Judea and Samaria "should have all the power to govern themselves, but none of the power to threaten us." What does this mean in practice, and how does this fit into the two-state solution embraced by the international community?

While much of the world has been obsessed with solving the Arab-Israeli conflict by focusing on Israeli territorial withdrawals, few take into account the unique set of serious security challenges that Israel faces. Judging by the amount of media attention, many would be forgiven for wrongly believing that Israel is a giant country. 


In reality, the Jewish state's territory is one of the tiniest in the world. Israel within the Green Line is similar in size to Wales or New Jersey. Yet unlike these territories, Israel is still surrounded by hostile neighbors who seek her destruction.

Abba Eban, Israel's legendary late foreign minister, famously referred to the pre-1967 lines as "Auschwitz borders." By that, the dovish Israeli diplomat was referring to the danger and insecurity that accompany Israel's nine-mile waistline, while facing hostile neighbors. By comparison, New York's compact Manhattan Island is more than 13 miles long.

Israel's current security challenges from Hamas-run Gaza would pale in comparison if Israel were to completely withdraw militarily from Judea and Samaria without proper security arrangements. The weak and ineffective Ramallah regime would quickly collapse and be replaced with Hamas, just as had occurred in Gaza.

From the commanding heights of Judea and Samaria, terrorists would seriously threaten Israel's major population centers around Jerusalem and metropolitan Tel Aviv. Terrorists could easily target civilian planes going to and from Israel's Ben-Gurion International Airport, which is located merely four miles from the Green Line. What has become a daily threat for the residents of the Israeli border town of Sderot adjacent to Gaza could become a reality for Israel's major population centers in the center of the country.


The Trump administration is expected to unveil its much talked-about Arab-Israeli peace plan soon. French President Emmanuel Macron has insisted that in the absence of an American peace plan, France will soon present its own alternative.

The key UN Resolution 242 from 1967 is often referred to as the legal basis for settling the Arab-Israeli territorial dispute. Ironically, since it was drafted and passed in a pre-PLO propaganda era, the word "Palestinian" does not appear anywhere in the text. 

The resolution urges Israel to withdraw from some but not necessarily all disputed territories. The international community today frequently overlooks this key distinction. The resolution also conditions this on a requirement that Israel be able to live in "peace within secure and recognized boundaries free from threats or acts of force."

Critics have argued that what Israel and Netanyahu are prepared to offer the Arab population in the disputed territories does not constitute a "real state." Netanyahu has responded by stating that he prefers content over labels. In practice, Israel has no interest in interfering in the daily lives of the Arab population in Judea and Samaria. Most of them are already today ruled by Ramallah. 

However, due to its vulnerable narrow borders and unique security challenges, Israel needs to retain overall security control over the tiny airspace and the strategically crucial Jordan Valley that blocks potential enemy forces from the east.



Israel has also insisted that the potentially new Arab entity must be demilitarized without a standing army. Several dozen countries, including affluent Iceland, lack a standing military but are nevertheless defined as countries.

As long as the regimes in Ramallah and Gaza prioritize Israel's destruction over the well-being of their own populations, the two-state plan will remain an unattainable pipe dream, no matter how many peace plans are launched by the international community.

Numerous countries, including America, Britain, France, and Turkey maintain overseas military bases as part of their national security. These bases are often located thousands of miles from their capitals. It would be hypocritical to deny the Jewish state the right to maintain proper security arrangements on its doorstep.

Originally published at JNS.org - reposted with permission.


Other News

May 20, 2019Christian Athletes Being Purged For Posting Biblical Beliefs On Social Media

In Australia, star rugby player Israel Folau has caused a national debate after being released from his team for posting Bible verses that...

May 20, 2019Next Generation Warfare: From EMP To CHAMP

For years there has been warnings about the apocalyptic scenarios an EMP pulse blast could cause upon our nation. Now a new type of weapo...

May 20, 2019Canadians Forced To Sponsor Government Media While Alternative Voices Silenced

Here's how the Canadians will deal with citizen journalism and narrative debunking--they'll force the taxpayers to subsidize corporate new...

May 20, 2019The Iranian Government's 40 Years Of Hatred Towards America

The argument that the US must take an apologetic stance towards the theocratic establishment of Iran is being repeatedly made without the ...

May 17, 2019Blood Money: Hollywood & Georgia Clash Over Abortion

In a pairing you might expect to encounter only in a fanciful Tinsel Town script, conservative, Bible-belt Georgia has become known as the...

May 17, 2019Total Catastrophe For U.S. Corn Production Will Impact All Of Us

2019 is turning out to be a nightmare that never ends for the agriculture industry. Thanks to endless rain and unprecedented flooding, fi...

May 17, 2019Why Is An Episcopal Church Hosting Islamic Anti-Israel BDS Speakers

On Tuesday May 14, Redeemer Episcopal Church in Astoria, Queens hosted an event called "Palestinian Expulsion and Resistance: The Nakba, B...

Get Breaking News