ARTICLE

No, Mr. President, Two States Won't 'Work Best'

News Image By Stephen Flatow/JNS.org October 09, 2018
Share this article:

How did U.S. President Donald Trump go from "People have been talking about the two-state solution for so many years now; it so far hasn't worked" in February to last week's "I like a two-state solution. That's what I think works best"?

The answer, as with so many things involving Donald Trump, is that we just don't know. But one thing is certain: He didn't arrive at this new position after looking at any actual maps of what Israel would look like if a Palestinian state were created.


Because nobody who realizes that establishing a Palestinian state would reduce Israel to just nine miles wide could possibly advocate such an outcome--except, of course, somebody who seeks to facilitate Israel's destruction.

Take a look at a map of Judea-Samaria (the "West Bank"). Notice the cities with the largest Palestinian Arab populations. Hebron is first, Nablus (Shechem) is second. The third largest is Tulkarm. The fifth largest is Qalqilyah. Obviously, Tulkarm and Qalqilyah would have to be included in any Palestinian state.

Now notice where Tulkarm and Qalqilyah are located. They are on the far western edge of what would be a Palestinian state. They are a little more than nine miles from the Mediterranean Sea. That is, nine miles of Israel.

Meaning that if "Palestine" is created, then Israel will be just nine miles wide at its mid-section. That's not as wide as Washington, D.C. Or even the Bronx.

Nine miles wide. An enemy army would be able to cut the country in two in a matter of minutes. A terrorist with a shoulder-fired rocket, standing inside the border of the new Palestinian state, would be able to shoot down a plane landing at Israel's major airport. Pedestrians in Israel's capital, Jerusalem, could be targeted by Arab snipers--as they were before June 1967.

There's a very important reason why advocates of a Palestinian state call their solution "the two-state solution," instead of "the nine-miles-wide plan."


The phrase "two-state solution" sounds fair. You have two warring parties, so you give each of them a state. And "solution" sounds so promising; a problem is solved. But the term is deeply deceptive because it doesn't tell you anything about the size of the two states--so you have no idea whether that would "work best" or not.

"Two-state solution" is nothing more than a slogan. A sound bite. An appealing phrase with no content.

If you add some content--if you call it what it really is, the "Nine Miles Wide Plan"--then you understand what a Palestinian state actually would mean for Israel. And with that information, you can make a much more educated decision as to whether or not you want to support it.

Palestinian advocates don't want you to have that information. They don't want you to think it through, to look at a map, to see if it's genuinely a safe plan for Israel's future. They want to lull you into thinking that it will bring peace, and if that isn't enough to convince you, then they will try to scare you with the old "demographic time bomb" threat.

That's the claim that because of the high Arab birthrate, Israel will have to agree to a Palestinian state or it will become an apartheid-like ruler over the Palestinians. Nonsense. Yitzhak Rabin resolved that problem way back in 1995, when he withdrew Israel's forces from the cities where 98 percent of the Palestinians reside. 

Now they are residents of the Palestinian Authority, and they vote in Palestinian elections. They will never be Israeli citizens, will never vote in Israeli elections, and will never threaten Israel's Jewish demographic majority.

There may be no solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in our generation; not all international conflicts have one. But certainly whittling Israel down to nine miles wide is not the answer. Would somebody please show President Trump a map?

Originally published at JNS.org - reposted with permission.


Other News

October 22, 2018America's Coming Demographic Winter: US Birth Rates Fall To All-Time Low

The elite have worked very hard to slow down birth rates all over the world, and their efforts appear to be working. Just as we have witn...

October 22, 2018Christians Risking All To Share Faith With Muslims

Throughout the Muslim world, the act of evangelization is itself a crime that carries stiff punishment and in many countries, conversion f...

October 22, 20185 Things They Don't Tell You Before You Start Watching Porn

Nobody told you where your porn usage would lead. They didn't tell you the high price you would pay in so many areas of your life....

October 22, 2018Justice For ISIS Terrorists? Not In The UK Or Canada

Why do America's allies find it so hard to bring ISIS terrorists to justice?...

October 18, 2018The Rising Threat Of A Global Pandemic

We've faced scares from bird flu, swine flu, Ebola, and other diseases, but we've avoided a global pandemic. Some experts believe we are ...

October 18, 2018LGBT Activists Overplay Their Hand - A Win In The Courts For Religious Freedom

The city of Atlanta had the gall to tell it's fire chief that if his personal beliefs didn't agree with the homosexual lifestyle he could ...

October 18, 2018World Ignores Myanmar Persecution Of Christians

Myanmar is a dictatorship and Christians are perceived as a threat to dictators and warlords. They see in the Word of God a challenge to t...

Get Breaking News