ARTICLE

The Idea Of 'Israel Victory' Gains Strength

News Image By Daniel Pipes/JNS.org July 09, 2018
Share this article:

What do Israelis think of Israel winning and the Palestinians losing?

It's a radical idea, very different from the 50-year-old-and-counting win-win assumption of "land for peace" that has transfixed governments and monopolized their attention. That old idea holds that putting Palestinians and Israelis in a room together will prompt them to settle their differences. 


On the cusp of the 25th anniversary of the Oslo Accords, we know precisely how well that worked out: Israelis gave real land, and Palestinians rewarded them with false promises of peace.

Indeed, according to a poll commissioned by the Middle East Forum and carried out by Rafi Smith of Smith Consulting, only 33 percent of Jewish Israelis (and about half that number among those who voted for the current government) still believe in land for peace, and about the same small number still believe in Oslo. So, the old ways not only failed but are deeply unpopular. What takes their place?

One alternative is the Middle East Forum's "Israel Victory" initiative, and it polls well. Respondents were asked, "Do you agree or disagree with the proposition that it will only be possible to reach a peace agreement with the Palestinians when they recognize they have lost their war against Israel?" Fifty-eight percent agreed. This has the makings of a revolution.

Drilling down deeper, an identical 58 percent also agree that "despite Israel's many victories over the Palestinians, most Palestinians continue to think they can eliminate the Jewish State of Israel." Fully 65 percent agree that "none of the military conflicts to date with the Palestinians have produced an Israeli victory or a decisive result, and therefore the Israeli-Palestinian conflict perseveres." 


An even larger number, 70 percent, hold that "is it necessary for the Palestinian Authority to recognize Israel as the Jewish state before Israel agrees to continue negotiations with it."

And 77 percent are ready, the next time Hamas attacks from Gaza or Hezbollah from Lebanon, to "let the IDF win," meaning they want Israeli military operations to continue until the other side recognizes it has lost. (That is very much not current IDF policy, which is to halt military operations as soon as the other side agrees to a ceasefire.)

After a quarter-century of lopsided negotiations in which the Israelis gave up tangible benefits (land) in return for false promises (peace), these poll numbers confirm a hunger in Israel for truth and courage. Roughly two-thirds of the population has concluded that the conflict can only be ended by abandoning failed negotiations and instead showing the Palestinians that their case is hopeless.

But Israeli leaders are shy to assert this proposition because every American president from Jimmy Carter to Barack Obama has discouraged them from taking bold steps, insisting on the discredited but pleasantly neutral-sounding land-for-peace formulation.

Enter Donald Trump. The Middle East Forum poll asked about him and 59 percent of Smith's Jewish Israeli sample calls him "certainly the most pro-Israel U.S. president to date."

As readers may be aware, I have my doubts about this judgment, seeing Trump as driven by an anti-Iran project of which Israel is but a small part.

But Israel Victory offers the president an unequaled opportunity to prove his Zionist credibility. If he lets Israel achieve the victory that both it and the Palestinians need to move forward, leaving a tedious and harmful conflict behind, he will have made a huge and constructive change for which all sides eventually will profusely thank him.

Originally published at JNS.org - reposted with permission.


Other News

December 11, 2018U.S. Life Expectancy Falling - The 2 Biggest Reasons Why Will Surprise You

When I was growing up, life expectancy was continually rising, and it was generally believed that it would keep rising for many decades to...

December 11, 2018From Pearl Harbor To Salvation: A Lesson For Our Generation

Pearl Harbor was for the Greatest Generation what September 11 is for ours: a national memory. As we remember and honor those who served, ...

December 11, 2018UN True Colors Revealed After Failure To Condemn Hamas Terrorism

Thanks to the "peace-loving UN," December 2018 may well go down in history as the day the UN gave the green light to Palestinian terrorist...

December 11, 2018Your Tax Dollars At Work: Inciting Next Generation Of Israel-Haters On Campus

Thanks to the Middle East Studies programs as most colleges across the nation there is only one nation state in the entire world they all ...

December 10, 2018Historic Debt Is At The Core Of Our Economic Decline

A sordid theater of blame has exploded over the state of the U.S. economy, with fingers pointing everywhere except (in most cases) at the ...

December 10, 2018Liberal Churches: Compromised & Infiltrated

If the gay liberation activists could convince liberal denominations to support their cause and erode the resolve of weak-kneed churches t...

December 10, 2018Fog Of War Can’t Conceal Hezbollah’s Plotting

Hezbollah may be biding its time quietly at the moment, but it very well may retaliate – not just verbally, but also physically, in the ba...

Get Breaking News