ARTICLE

The Myth Of A 'Demilitarized' Palestinian State

News Image By Stephen M. Flatow/JNS.org June 13, 2018
Share this article:

The phrase "demilitarized Palestinian state" is the very definition of an oxymoron--"a figure of speech in which apparently contradictory terms appear in conjunction."

Proponents of Palestinian statehood use the term "demilitarized" as a propaganda weapon. They know that Palestinian Authority spokesmen have consistently rejected the idea that a state would be demilitarized. 


And they know that the idea of demilitarizing a dictatorship has never been successfully implemented in history. But they use the phrase because it's the only way to sell their awful plan.

The creation of a Palestinian state in most or all of Judea-Samaria means that Israel would be nine miles wide at one point. The idea that a Palestinian state would have an army of its own is nothing less than terrifying. It means that Israel would be in mortal danger from the moment "Palestine" is created.

So, the only way for Palestinian advocates to push their cause is to pretend that somehow, it would be demilitarized. Look at the new poll carried out by the American Jewish Committee about attitudes among American Jews and Israelis.

The appropriate wording for a question about a Palestinian state would have been: "Do you support the creation of a Palestinian state alongside Israel, which would then be nine miles wide?"

At a very minimum, the wording could have been: "Do you support the creation of a Palestinian state alongside Israel?"

Instead, here's how the American Jewish Committee phrased it: "In the current situation, do you favor or oppose a two-state solution through the establishment of a demilitarized Palestinian state on the West Bank?"

Well, when you phrase it that way, it doesn't sound too bad--and sure enough, 31 percent of American Jews "strongly favor" such a state, and another 28 percent "somewhat" favor it. Thus, the headline: "59 percent of American Jews Support Palestinian State!"

But that's a lie. They don't "support a Palestinian state." They support a mythical state that can never come into being because it's an impossibility.

The truth, in fact, is that the P.A. regime is already militarized. The Oslo II accord of 1995 permitted the P.A. to have a 12,000-man security force in Judea-Samaria. That force now numbers more than 30,000 men.

A new report from the Washington Institute on Near East Policy, which leans left with regard to Israel, analyzes the history and the status of the P.A. security forces. The report was authored by a former senior P.A. official, Ghaith Al-Omari, together with journalist Neri Zilber.

"By late 1998," according to the report, "the P.A. security services, as they were then known, had in almost every regard violated the letter of the agreements reached with Israel ... [The P.A. became] one of the most heavily policed territories in the world." 

The P.A. was supposed to show Israel lists of those whom it was hiring for the forces, so Israel could veto known terrorists. Instead, "Israeli government officials were also aware that the P.A. was not submitting complete lists of these security personnel, to obfuscate the total number under arms and to bypass Israeli background checks for those with terrorist backgrounds."
The report continues: "Similarly, a proliferation of weapons was occurring, both in quantity and quality, well beyond that stipulated in Oslo II. By one estimate, there were at least 40,000 more weapons than allowed in the agreement, including RPGs, mortars, mines, grenade launchers and sniper rifles; also being developed was a small-scale indigenous manufacturing capacity for hand grenades and other ammunition. "

The P.A.'s security forces already constitute the nucleus of an army. If the P.A. were to become a sovereign state, there would be no way for Israel to prevent it from turning those forces into a full-fledged army, except by invading. What is the likelihood that any Israeli government would order an invasion of "Palestine," knowing the international sanctions and pressure Israel would then face?

Of course, in such a scenario, all the "peace" activists who are now claiming there could be a demilitarized state would be the first to argue that "Palestine" needs tanks, planes and missiles to "defend itself."

How sad that a long-established and respected organization, the American Jewish Committee, is knowingly perpetuating the dangerous myth that a Palestinian state could be demilitarized.

Originally published at JNS.org - reposted with permission.


Other News

October 22, 2018America's Coming Demographic Winter: US Birth Rates Fall To All-Time Low

The elite have worked very hard to slow down birth rates all over the world, and their efforts appear to be working. Just as we have witn...

October 22, 2018Christians Risking All To Share Faith With Muslims

Throughout the Muslim world, the act of evangelization is itself a crime that carries stiff punishment and in many countries, conversion f...

October 22, 20185 Things They Don't Tell You Before You Start Watching Porn

Nobody told you where your porn usage would lead. They didn't tell you the high price you would pay in so many areas of your life....

October 22, 2018Justice For ISIS Terrorists? Not In The UK Or Canada

Why do America's allies find it so hard to bring ISIS terrorists to justice?...

October 18, 2018The Rising Threat Of A Global Pandemic

We've faced scares from bird flu, swine flu, Ebola, and other diseases, but we've avoided a global pandemic. Some experts believe we are ...

October 18, 2018LGBT Activists Overplay Their Hand - A Win In The Courts For Religious Freedom

The city of Atlanta had the gall to tell it's fire chief that if his personal beliefs didn't agree with the homosexual lifestyle he could ...

October 18, 2018World Ignores Myanmar Persecution Of Christians

Myanmar is a dictatorship and Christians are perceived as a threat to dictators and warlords. They see in the Word of God a challenge to t...

Get Breaking News